Social media has taken over in ways beyond what anyone ever expected. For independent musicians, it’s great for reaching new fans… isn’t it? Or is it great until the algorithm changes and you go from thousands of views to being buried under fat cat videos and viral dance trends… The truth is, you don’t own your audience on socials; the platform does. But email is different. With it, you aren’t at the mercy of a constantly changing algorithm. You just send your message, and it goes directly where you want it to: their inbox. If you want to build a reliable fanbase that lasts, buys tickets, supports your music, and sticks around for the long haul, email is one of the best tools you’ve got. In this post, we’ll explain everything you need to know to build the ultimate email strategy that drives real results beyond algorithms. Let’s dive in…
How To Build a Real Fanbase in the Age of Algorithms with Email Marketing
Why Email Beats Social ReachÂ
Think of social media like renting an apartment. You decorate the space and invite people over, but you don’t own it. The landlord (aka the platform) can change the rules at any time, and you literally just have to… deal with it. With email, you own your list. Nobody can decide for you who gets to see your message. There’s no algorithm messing with your big announcement; you send it, it lands in their inbox, simple as that.
On top of that, email still gets way better engagement than socials. (Yes, really.) The average open rate of 42.35% for email is a pretty big difference from the 0.50% average engagement rate on Instagram and 2.5% on TikTok. And if you want to sell tickets, promote your new track, or share something that means a lot to you, you want as many people to see it as possible. And in reality, new apps will always come and go, algorithms will keep changing, but email isn’t going anywhere. It offers a direct line of communication to the people who care the most about what you’re doing.
Now that’s something worth putting some real effort into.
How to Grow Your Email List
If you’re starting from zero, don’t worry! Every great list starts with just a couple names. The key is giving people a reason to hand over their email that feels worth it to them (and easy for them to do). For example, here’s what you can do:
- Offer freebies or “fan perks.” This could be an unreleased track, a behind-the-scenes video, a sample pack, or even a discount code for merch. Just make it feel like something uniquely you that they can’t get anywhere else.
- Get signups at shows. Put a QR code at your merch table, have a tablet for quick sign-ins, or run a raffle for a free t-shirt/vinyl/poster. This is super low-effort for them and gives you instant connections.
- Promote it on socials. Post a teaser of something exclusive and tell people the full thing is only going to email subscribers. (Make FOMO work in your favor.)
- Add it everywhere you can online. Your website, Linktree, YouTube video descriptions, even your Spotify “About” section. Honestly, anywhere fans might stumble across you is a good place.
You don’t need a massive list to start seeing results. Even 50–100 people who care about what you’re doing are more valuable than thousands of random followers who scroll past your posts without a second thought. Why? Because when people actually care about you and your music, they are way more likely to take action. That means buying tickets, streaming your music, sharing your stuff, etc. We’re talking quality over quantity here.
And even if you start with 50 people, stick with it, nurture it, and you’ll be surprised how fast it grows.
What to Send Your Fans
Now that you’ve got people coming over to your list, what else can you send them? Think of your emails like a backstage pass. You need to give fans something exclusive, something they can’t get anywhere else.
Newsletters are a great way to share updates on shows, releases, press, or behind-the-scenes moments. (Just make sure you keep it personal, like you’re talking directly to them.) Drops and exclusives, like early access to tickets, new tracks, or limited merch, make fans feel like VIPs. Personal stories are another great way to connect, like sharing the inspiration behind a song, a funny studio moment, or a little life update. The more human you are, the more invested your audience will be.
Even things like milestones and recaps, like year-end roundups, tour highlights, or best moments, help fans feel like they’re a part of your journey. And speaking of fans, don’t forget fan spotlights! Feature fan art, covers, or messages to build community and show appreciation.
The key is variety. Don’t just blast out promotions. Mix in stories, sneak peeks, and personal notes so fans look forward to every email. It needs to feel like a real connection, not a sales pitch.
——
đź“š Want to learn something new? Check these out…
How To Build a Scalable Music Business Without Selling Your Soul
Why Copyright Registration Matters More Than Ever in the Age of AI
How To Use A/B Testing for Better Music Marketing
What is a Lyric Sheet and When Do I Need One?
——
How to Automate Your Emails
One of the best parts about email is that you don’t have to do everything manually. Automation lets you set up messages that send themselves, so you can stay connected with fans without constantly stressing about it. There are a few popular options for artists, depending on what you need:
đź“Ś Mailchimp: A beginner-friendly option with plenty of ready-to-go templates and a visual editor that makes it easy to design emails quickly.
đź“Ś Kit: Excellent for automations, audience segmentation, and building welcome sequences or drip campaigns.
đź“Ś Buttondown: Simple, clean, and perfect if you want a more personal, text-based newsletter style.
With these, you can start setting up a ton of automations like a welcome sequence, birthday emails, segmented tour announcements, or drip campaigns around releases. A welcome sequence is a great place to start. This is when someone signs up, they’d get a few automated emails introducing them to you, your story, and your most popular tracks. Next, birthday emails are another great way to connect, where you can offer a small discount, early access to a new song, or even just a personal note saying “happy birthday!” That personal touch is everything to a fan.
You can also segment your list by location so only fans in relevant cities get tour announcements. In addition, you should also consider setting up drip or countdown campaigns around releases. This is where, for example, you could send a 3-email series: one teasing the release, one sharing behind-the-scenes content, and a final email on release day with links to stream or buy.
Automating things like these saves time, keeps your fans engaged, and makes sure the right message gets to the right people at the right moment without you having to sit at your computer and physically hit that “send” button every time. *cue lizard hitting button meme*
Monetization & Re-Engagement Tips đź’¸
Even the most engaged fans can go quiet sometimes, but that’s where re-engagement emails come in handy. With these, you can set up automated messages for subscribers who haven’t opened your emails in a while. Just a quick “we miss you” note, a fun poll, or a small exclusive perk can bring them back without feeling too pushy. (Think of those aggressive messages from the DuoLingo owl telling you to return to your lessons, but maybe a little less aggressive…)
Similar to segmenting by location for tour announcements, you can also target other groups in your list. For example, share a special offer with your most active subscribers or send content tailored to fans who haven’t opened your emails in a while. These targeted messages feel personal, boost engagement, and make your campaigns more effective overall.
You can also experiment with micro-actions that keep your fans involved, like surveys, voting on merch designs, or letting them pick the set list for your next show. Small touches like these keep your list active, make fans feel valued, and turn casual subscribers into supporters who actually participate.
To wrap things up…
At the end of the day, building a real fanbase isn’t about chasing algorithms or racking up faceless followers. It’s about connecting with people who actually care about your music and giving them reasons to stick around. By optimizing your email marketing efforts, you’re setting yourself up for fans who show up, support your work, and share your journey. And that’s really what it’s all about.
Good luck!
Other Stories You May Like
Meet Our Team: Christine Su
